New Haven-Style Pizza in the Heart of West Chester
Pizza West Chester serves artisan New Haven-style pizza from 136 E Market Street in downtown West Chester, PA. Rated 8.4 by Dave Portnoy from Barstool Sports, we keep it simple — hand-crafted dough, sliced provolone and mozzarella, house-made sauce, and a perfectly crispy crust. Walk in, grab a pie, and taste why we sell out daily.
Speer Madanat
Owner & Pizza Maker
136 E Market Street
Downtown West Chester
8.4 out of 10
Dave Portnoy Pizza Review
No phone, no delivery
Cash & credit accepted
Speer Madanat's vision is clear: a well-done, blistered crust with an assertive, Jersey tomato-based sauce, two different mozzarellas, and a sprinkling of umami-packed Grana Padano at the end. No gimmicks, no delivery apps, no reservations. Just walk in, grab a number, and wait for the best slice in West Chester.
Dave Portnoy visited and rated Pizza West Chester an 8.4, praising the crispy crust and quality ingredients.
"For this West Chester pizza with crispy crust, you'll have to walk in." Featured in the Inquirer's food section.
One of the highest-rated pizza spots in the West Chester area with a loyal following that comes back every week.