Pizza West Chester

New Haven-Style Pizza in the Heart of West Chester

Our Menu

Pizza West Chester serves artisan New Haven-style pizza from 136 E Market Street in downtown West Chester, PA.

Whole Pies

Classic Cheese Pie

Hand-crafted dough topped with sliced provolone and mozzarella, house-made tomato sauce, and shredded mozzarella. The one that started it all.

$20
Whole Pies

Pepperoni Pie

Our classic cheese pie loaded with premium pepperoni. Crispy edges, perfect char.

$22
Whole Pies

White Pie

Creamy ricotta, mozzarella, and a drizzle of extra virgin olive oil on our signature crust. No red sauce.

$20
Slices

Pepperoni Slice

A single slice of our pepperoni pie. Perfect for a quick lunch.

$4.50
Slices

Cheese Slice

A single slice of our classic cheese pie.

$4

What People Are Saying

Rated an 8.4 — one of the best slices in the area. The crust is perfect.

Dave P.Barstool Sports

Best pizza in West Chester, hands down. The cheese pie is simple and perfect. We come every week.

Sarah M.2 weeks ago

New Haven-style done right. Crispy, charred crust, quality ingredients. They sell out for a reason.

Mike R.1 month ago

Come Grab a Pie

136 E Market Street, West Chester, PA 19382

Walk-in only. Cash and credit accepted. We often sell out — come early!